Focus on Hungary

Milla demonstration, 23 October 2012 (c) Gabriella Csoszó
The Heinrich Böll Foundation has compiled a dossier containing articles and interviews on the situation in Hungary since the right-wing government came to power in April 2010. Our intention is to raise awareness about the changes in the domain of public life in Hungary at “half-time” – two years before the next parliamentary elections.

Readers will find that the arguments and opinions presented in the dossier provide an acute, sometimes trenchant critique of the current government and its policies. We see our role in supporting the democratic voices in Hungary and raising public attention in Europe with regard to critical developments in our common political space. Therefore, we wanted to provide a platform for oppositional analysts and civil-society actors (who largely lack access to mainstream media channels in Hungary today). Our intention is not to engage in fruitless polemics, but rather to foster dialogue on the future course of Hungary and the broader topic of sustaining democracy during a period of crisis.

The dossier’s articles have been grouped into four sections: The first, entitled “Current Developments” will contain texts commenting on current events in Hungary. The second section, “Background Analysis”, comprises a number of articles written over the course of the last two years on important events and salient topics. Readers who wish to obtain insight into socio-political trends are therefore recommended to read the analyses presented here. It is at this point that we would like to thank the editors of the journal Osteuropa for making available to us a few articles written for the special issue “Quo vadis, Hungaria?”. The texts are interesting from a different perspective as well: They provide insights into the moods and perspectives of oppositional analysts and public actors, and into how these have evolved over the last two years. Readers will find that the voices presented here do not form a harmonious ensemble; while they all criticise the current government, they are in considerable disagreement on how to relate to those in power and how to respond to the authoritarian turn in governance.

This latter question is taken up and addressed in more detail in the third section, “Democratic Renewal”, where our authors (some of whom are active in burgeoning civil-society initiatives) scrutinise the conditions necessary for renewing Hungarian democracy. In order to present some of the women and men driving these citizens’ initiatives, we also provide video interviews with “agents of change”, many of whom are largely unknown outside Hungary. The dossier’s final section, “Implications for Europe”, will comprise texts looking at events and processes in Hungary from a broader perspective: the implications of these events and processes for the fate of democracy in other corners of the continent and on the level of the European Union.

We hope that this dossier will help our readers get a better grasp of the controversies surrounding the political changes in Hungary, and thereby involve members of the European public in the crucial debate on democracy in a changing Europe. This debate is not limited to current developments in Hungary. We see democracy as a never-finished task. There is no guarantee against retrogression, and it’s always up to citizens to reinforce democratic structures and procedures through their engagement in the public sphere.

Ralf Fücks, President, Heinrich Böll Foundation
Eva van de Rakt, Director, Heinrich Böll Foundation Prague (Eva.vandeRakt@cz.boell.org)
Kristóf Szombati, Co-Editor of the dossier, Hungary (Kristof.Szombati@hu.boell.org)

Current Developments

Interview

“This ambiguity was no longer tenable”

December 5, 2012 - András Schiffer, re-elected parliamentary leader of the green liberal political party LMP, about the party’s electoral strategy for 2014 and its rejection to join the new political movement Together 2014 ("T14"). more»

The Story of the "Hungarian Orange"

- November 23, 2012 - Berlin-based Hungarian artist Artúr van Balen has travelled to Hungary to join the opposition protests in Budapest on the 23rd of October. With the help of around 15 artists and activists van Balen created the "Hungarian Orange", a 5 meter long, 3.5 meter high inflatable lemon, which they brought to the protests. But not everyone was amused by the playful object. Artúr van Balen more»

Opposition in Hungary: Left-of-centre Co-operation - the Risky Imperative?

- October 29, 2012 - As expected, the 56th anniversary of the hungarian revolution occasioned a symbolic battle between the Prime Minister and his left-of-centre opposition, with both sides seeking to present themselves as the true heirs of 1956. Whereas Orbán and Fidesz clearly won the battle of numbers, the show was stolen by Gordon Bajnai, the former Prime Minister. Kristóf Szombati more»

The new Education Act – regulation and centralisation

- September 6, 2012 - A chain of rapid and unprecedented changes in Hungary’s Higher Education Act have been adopted and implemented recently by the government of Viktor Orbán. The changes share the intention of centralising power and establishing supreme control over all levels of education. Zsófia Deák more»

Background Analysis

Could Viktor Orbán’s Dream Come True?

June 14, 2012 - Prime Minister Viktor Orbán has projected fifteen to twenty years of governance in a “central political space”, rather than the customary shifts of power between left and right. In the elections 2010, Fidesz had the support of roughly half of all voters, and during its first half-year the new government enjoyed strong public approval. But since then the political landscape has changed dramatically. Peter Kreko more»

From Schmitt to Áder: Is there any Difference?

- May 30, 2012 - Hungary's former president Pal Schmitt's loyalty to Fidesz and Mr Orbán was so exaggerated that he wasn't taken seriously as an autonomous political figure. With János Áder Fidesz and Mr Orbán have chosen long-time party member, who is perceived as a more independent figure. But how autnonmous is the new president really?  György Vári more»

Understanding Hungary?

- May 18, 2012 - In a recently published online article György Schöpflin, Hungarian political scientist and member of the European Parliament for Viktor Orbán’s Fidesz party, laments that foreign countries do not understand Hungary. For Schöpflin Hungary is a “small culture with its own very different language”, which is not heard by the rest of the world. Wolfgang Klotz, director of the Heinrich Böll Foundation, analyzes the values of Hungary's conservatives. Wolfgang Klotz more»

The Crisis of Democracy in Hungary

- February 3, 2012 - For twenty years, the Hungarian political system was a liberal democracy characterised by a multiparty system, free elections, free media and independent courts. But in the past years the country has returned to an authoritarian system. Andras Bozoki, former Minister of Culture between 2005 and 2006 takes a closer look at Hungary's transition away from democracy. Andras Bozoki more»
Hungarian Parliament in the rain

The beginning of the end?

- January 6, 2012 - Hungary’s new constitution, adopted without a referendum or the support of parties in opposition, came into force on the 1st of January 2012. In the last week of 2011 members of the ruling coalition – despite warnings from their fellow MPs and the country’s international partners – passed a number of bills which break the pillars of the liberal democratic edifice, erected just two decades ago to replace an authoritarian system of rule. Kristóf Szombati more»

The Chokehold of Populism - Hungary’s Economy

- December 8, 2011 -

In the 1990s, Hungary was considered a role model for the socialist transformation of centrally planned economies in Eastern Europe. Today, economic growth in Hungary is lower, and public and private debt are considerably higher, than in other East Central European countries. The country was led into this plight by politicians who concealed the real situation with irresponsible populism, delayed reforms, and promised the moon. 

Sándor Richter more»

The betrayed republic

- May 22, 2011 - The new Hungarian Constitution disempowers the political community, curtails  fundamental rights and confronts citizens with the prospect of having to live in a state which exhibits authoritarian tendencies in general. But fatalism is not an option. Kristóf Szombati more»

Sticks in the spokes of the “booth revolution”

- May 14, 2011 - Kristóf Szombati analyzes the the difficulties and obstacles that Fidesz’s governance has created for itself and asks what this may spell for the future. According to Szombati, in order to assess the impact of forces that may push a governmental force down, it is necessary to formulate an idea of the forces that lifted it up and to ask for the expectations that Hungarian voters and international investors, money-lenders and politicians had vis-à-vis the new government. Kristóf Szombati more»

Autocracy in Action - Hungary under Orbán

- March 12, 2011 - Ever since Viktor Orbán came to power, Hungarian politics has resembled a football match where the captain of one team can change the rules at will, appoint the referees and even eject members of the opposing team from the game. Orbán writes laws that are crafted with surgical precision for individual persons or groups and uses intimidation and blackmail to push forward a change of elites and a redistribution of property.
Bálint Magyar more»

Media Democracy, Hungarian Style

- January 17, 2011 - In other countries, the political control of the media is mainly effected through economic pressure. It seems that in Hungary this mechanism worked insufficiently, thus necessitating direct political control through legal means and a monopoly on the organs controlling the media. An article by Wolfgang Klotz more»
Four men in front of flags of Hungary and EU

What is happening to Hungary?

- January 13, 2011 - Hungary was long considered a model for democracy in the former Eastern Bloc countries. It currently hits the headlines because of the controversial media laws and other moves by the national conservative Fidesz party, which endanger essential elements of the constitutional framework. By Peter Rauschenberger more»

Democratic Renewal

Conference Summary

The State and Future of Democracy in Hungary and CEE - Ways out of the Crisis

November 26, 2012 -

The conference, which took place on the October 4th 2012 was organized by Védegylet (Protect the Future), the One Million for the Freedom of the Hungarian Press Movement (Milla) and the Heinrich Böll Foundation. It had a double objective: to discuss problems of democracy in Central and Eastern Europe and to present a new project  on democratic renewal to the Hungarian public. 

Kristof Szombati more»
Viktor Orbán at the EPP Congress 2009 in Warsaw

A Turning Point for Hungary?

- May 15, 2012 - The Hungarian political system rests on a powerfully centralised party machine, a viable alternative is not in sight. The opposition is scattered and lacks of democratic structures and identity. What are potential sources for a democrativ change? László Lengyel and Eszter Nova (Financial Research Institute in Budapest) about possible sources of change in a country not used to democratic self-defence.
László Lengyel and Eszter Nova more»
Portrait: György Konrád

Interview

The young people are slowly beginning to act

- January 14, 2011 - In December, the Hungarian Parliament passed a controversial media law to heavily fine radio and TV stations, newspapers, and websites whose reporting is considered to be "politically unbalanced.” The Hungarian author György Konrád discusses this new media law, his country’s EU Presidency, and resistance from the younger generation. György Konrád more»

Media: Agents of Change

Implications for Europe

Round Table Summary

Ways out of the crisis: the Future of European democracy

26. November 2012 - The expert round table “Ways out of the crisis: the Future of European democracy” took place on the 5th October 2012 at the Central European University. It was organized by the Heinrich Böll Foundation in cooperation with Central European University’s School of Public Policy, the Green European Foundation and Ecopolis Foundation. Kristof Szombati mehr»

The Gutting of Democracy. Hungary as a Trendsetter in Europe?

- July 5, 2012 - The political developments in Hungary show, that democracy must be defended, protected and maintained on a daily basis in many areas of society. It is also a preview of what could threaten other countries in Europe, if the civil society isn't careful. An interview with Gerald Häfner, Member of the Greens / EFA group in the European Parliament. more»

Hungary and the EU: Ways out of the Crisis

- May 30, 2012 -

The EU is dependent on intact democracies in the member states - if the EU wants to be democratic it cannot be indifferent to its democratically constituted members. But what options are available for influencing Hungary? And who are the relevant actors for a democratic change in the country?

Claudio Franzius more»

Seehofer rolls out the red carpet for Orbán

- April 15, 2012 - Despite international criticism of the undemocratic developments in Hungary, Bavarian Premier Horst Seehofer could not resist rolling out the red carpet for Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán during his visit to Munich in March 2012. Florian Hiermeier more»

The outlook for Slovak-Hungarian relations after the 2012 parliament elections

- May 21, 2012 - Under it's new Prime Minister Robert Fico and his Smer party, Slovakia has become the second Central European country after Hungary with a one-party government in power. Grigorij Mesežnikov, political scientist and president of the Institute for Public Affairs, analyzes the stuctural parallels and characteristics of the neighbouring countries' current political situations and draws a cautiously optimistic outlook on the future of the strained Slovak-Hungarian relations. Grigorij Mesežnikov more»

Viktor Orbán in Strasbourg: Veni, vidi, vici?

- January 26, 2012 - Last week, Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán participated in a plenary session of the European Parliament in Strasbourg. The agenda included current political developments in Hungary. Shortly beforehand, the European Commission had launched three infringement proceedings against the country. The Hungarian prime minister had invited himself to this session. Eva van de Rakt more»
Your basket

 

Terms of delivery
General Terms and Conditions, Heinrich Böll Foundation (hbf)

Following is information concerning your orders: postage and cost, data security policy, exemption clauses, and where to call for further information. more»
Help
A Step-by-step Guide on How to Place an Order on boell.de
A step-by-step guide, explaining in detail how to order publications on boell.de. more»
erene-banner The Climate Network-Transatlantic Solutions for a Low Carbon Economy