Supporting civil society under pressure – lessons from natural resource exploitation

Supporting civil society under pressure – lessons from natural resource exploitation

Cover: Supporting civil society under pressure
30. Jun. 2017 by Dr. Carolijn Terwindt and Christian Schliemann
Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung e.V. in cooperation with the European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights
For free
Place of Publication:
Date of Publication: June 2017
Number of Pages: 24
License: CC-BY-NC-ND 3.0

Civil society is under pressure worldwide. This is also true for civil society organisations and activists who protesting against land grabs and environmental degradation; who are standing up for a just utilization of resources and demanding the right to have a say in the matter.

This paper is a reflection of an ongoing research project of the Heinrich Böll Foundation and the European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights, designed to uncover common patterns and dynamics of restrictions on and coping strategies adopted by civil society actors in the specific context of natural resource exploitation.

It draws on case studies in India, Mexico, the Philippines, and South Africa based on desk-research and interviews with communities and organizations. After highlighting the economic context and legal framework behind the growing number of natural resource projects, the paper briefly sketches some common patterns of restrictions, as well the strengths and limits of prevalent response strategies. Current modes of response are predominantly reactive. While such emergency measures are absolutely necessary, they are not enough.

The paper calls for an analysis of the relation between community exclusion from decision-making and subsequent attacks and focuses on consultation procedures, which are thought to enable public participation, but more often end up being part and parcel of the process in which civil society is excluded. Those organizing to counter such exclusion and demanding to be heard are put under pressure to remain silent.


Table of contents:

  • Introduction
  • Shrinking space and natural resource governance
  • Pressures on communities and organizations advocating for sustainable natural resource governance
  • The business nexus of restrictions
  • Response strategies to counter restrictions
  • Shrinking space for consultations about natural resource governance
  • Conclusion

1 Comment

Add new comment

Add new comment

Arthur Larok

Very well written piece on an important subject. I look forward to more and should you be interested in carrying out a similar study in Uganda, please let me know. I will be most delighted to cooperate with you.

Thanks, Arthur